Article
How to Do a Competitor Analysis for a New Business
Updated · Team Fonda
Short answer
To do a competitor analysis, list every way your customers solve the problem today, pick five to eight of them, compare price, promise, strengths and complaints in one table, and read their customer reviews. Then write down the gap you can fill and the one thing you will do differently.
Key takeaways
- Your competitors include the spreadsheet, the agency and doing nothing, not only companies that look like yours.
- Five to eight competitors is enough. More than that turns research into procrastination.
- Customer reviews and public pages tell you more than guessing at their strategy.
- The output is a decision: where you will be different, and for whom.
- Redo a short version every few months, because the market moves.
What a competitor analysis is and why a new business needs one
A competitor analysis is a structured look at the other ways your future customers already solve the problem you want to solve. You write down who they are, what they promise, what they charge, what customers like and what customers complain about. The goal is not to copy anyone. The goal is to find a spot in the market where you can be clearly better or clearly different for a specific group of people.
New founders often skip this step for one of two reasons. Some believe they have no competition, which almost always means they have not looked hard enough. Others look once, feel scared by a big name and quit. Both are avoidable. Existing competitors prove that people pay to solve this problem, which is good news. Your job is to find out what is still unsolved.
This sits inside the wider work of market research and feeds directly into your value proposition. If you are still unsure the problem is real, run customer interviews alongside this work. The two methods check each other.
Step-by-step: how to do a competitor analysis
- Write the problem and the customer in one sentence. For example: "Freelance designers who lose hours chasing late invoices." Every later choice depends on this sentence, so keep it narrow.
- List every way people solve it today. Ask five people who have the problem what they use right now. Then search the way a customer would search and note the first pages of results, app store listings and marketplace categories.
- Sort them into three groups. Direct competitors sell nearly the same thing. Indirect competitors solve the same problem in a different way. Substitutes are the free or manual options, such as a spreadsheet, a friend or doing nothing.
- Pick five to eight to study. Choose at least two direct, two indirect and one substitute. Skip the rest for now.
- Collect the same facts for each one. Use the table in the next section so the comparison stays fair.
- Read what customers say. Reviews, forum threads and comment sections show real language and real frustration. Read the lowest rated reviews and the middle ones first.
- Find the gap and decide your angle. Look for a complaint that appears again and again, a customer group nobody serves well or a price or format nobody offers.
- Test the angle with real people. Describe your angle to buyers and see whether they care. A gap that nobody wants filled is not a gap.
What to collect about each competitor
Collect the same short list of facts for every competitor. Use only information you can see on their public pages or in public reviews, and note the date you checked, because pages change. If you cannot find something, write "not listed" rather than guessing.
Scroll sideways to see the whole table.
| What to record | Where to look | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Who they sell to | Home page, case studies, ad copy | Shows which customer group they chase and which they ignore |
| Main promise | Headline and first paragraph | Compare it with your value proposition |
| Price and how they charge | Pricing page, listings, menus | Shows where you can sit above, below or differently |
| Key features or offers | Product pages, feature lists | Reveals what customers expect as a minimum |
| How customers find them | Search results, social accounts, directories | Tells you which channels already work in this market |
| Praise in reviews | Review sites, app stores, forums | What you must match |
| Complaints in reviews | Same places, lowest ratings first | Where your opening may be |
| Date checked | Your own note | Keeps the table honest as it ages |
Fill one row per competitor in a spreadsheet. Keep quotes short and attribute them in your notes.
Worked example: a bookkeeping service for freelancers
Say you want to start a bookkeeping service for freelance photographers. This is an illustration, not real market data. Your one-sentence problem is: "Freelance photographers who dread tax season because their receipts and invoices are scattered."
You ask five photographers what they do today. Two use a spreadsheet, one pays a local accountant once a year, one uses a bookkeeping app and one does nothing until a deadline. You also search for the phrases they would type and find two bookkeeping apps and a few local firms that advertise to small businesses in general.
Your sorted list might look like this:
Scroll sideways to see the whole table.
| Competitor | Group | Promise | What reviewers say (example) |
|---|---|---|---|
| General bookkeeping app | Direct | Automates bookkeeping for any small business | Powerful but confusing for people with no accounting background |
| Local accounting firm | Direct | Full-service tax and bookkeeping | Helpful, but slow replies outside tax season |
| Freelancer invoice app | Indirect | Send invoices and track payment | Good for invoicing, nothing for expenses |
| Spreadsheet | Substitute | Free and flexible | Easy to start, easy to abandon by March |
| Doing nothing | Substitute | No cost today | Panic in the weeks before filing |
All entries in this table are invented for illustration. Your own table must come from pages and reviews you read.
The pattern in this example: existing options are either built for every business and feel heavy, or are cheap and incomplete. A gap might be a monthly service, in plain language, built around photography costs such as gear, travel and licensing. Your angle would then be "bookkeeping that speaks photographer." You still have to check that photographers will pay for it, which is why the next step is to talk to them.
How to read reviews and public pages
Reviews are a low-cost source of customer research. People write them when they are happy or angry, and they use the words they would use when describing the problem to a friend. Copy those phrases into your notes, because they make good headlines later.
- Read the one-star and two-star reviews for repeated complaints. One angry review is noise. Five reviews about the same problem is a pattern.
- Read the three-star reviews for "it is fine, but" sentences. These show what a good-enough product is missing.
- Read the five-star reviews for the job the customer hired the product to do. Their reason for loving it may differ from what the company advertises.
- Check the dates. A complaint from four years ago may be fixed.
- Be careful with small samples. Ten reviews do not describe a market, so treat what you find as a lead to test, not a fact.
Also read each competitor's pricing page, onboarding emails if you sign up for a free option, and the questions they answer in their help pages. Using a free trial or buying a cheap item as an ordinary customer is fair and often the most informative step. Do not misrepresent who you are, and do not copy their text or design.
Turn the table into a decision
A finished table is not the result. The result is a short statement you can act on. Write it in this shape: "For [customer group] who [problem], we will [different approach], unlike [main alternatives], which [weakness]." If you cannot complete it with something specific, you do not have an angle yet.
- Choose where to compete. Pick one of: a narrower customer group, a different price model, a simpler product, better service or a different channel.
- Decide what you will not do. If the leading competitor offers twenty features, name the three you will skip on purpose.
- Check the table for crowded spots. If every competitor makes the same promise, a new copy of it will struggle. Look elsewhere.
- Feed the result into your plan. Your angle becomes your positioning, your first message and part of your SWOT analysis.
Fonda follows the same order in its journey. Market and Key risks come in the Validate phase, before you commit to a business plan, so your competitor findings are tested against what real customers say. You can start free at Fonda or run a rough version yourself with the steps above.
Mistakes that make a competitor analysis useless
Scroll sideways to see the whole table.
| Mistake | What it looks like | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Only studying lookalikes | Your list has five companies that all sell the same thing | Add indirect options and substitutes |
| Studying too many | Forty rows, no decision | Cap it at eight and finish |
| Guessing at numbers | "They probably make a lot of money" | Write "not listed" or leave it out |
| Judging by their marketing | Believing a slick home page means happy customers | Read independent reviews |
| Never talking to customers | Table is complete, no buyer has seen it | Show your angle to five buyers |
| Doing it once | The table is two years old | Review it every few months |
A final caution about size. A large competitor can look unbeatable, but large companies are often slow to serve a small group well. Check whether the group you picked is one they actually care about before you decide the market is closed.
A simple monthly routine to keep it current
You do not need a research department. Once a month, spend an hour on three tasks. Re-check the pricing pages of your top three competitors and note any change. Search for new entrants using the same phrases your customers use. Read the newest reviews of each competitor and add any new repeated complaint to your notes.
Set a calendar reminder and keep everything in the same spreadsheet. Over a few months you will see which competitors change direction, which stay still and which weaknesses stay open. That history is more useful than any one snapshot, and it tells you when to adjust your message before a customer asks why you are different.
Frequently asked questions
How many competitors should I analyze?
Five to eight is enough for a new business: at least two direct competitors, two indirect ones and one substitute. More rows rarely change the decision.
What if I cannot find any competitors?
Look again for substitutes. If people solve the problem with a spreadsheet, an agency or by doing nothing, those are your competitors. A market with no alternatives at all can also mean few people pay to solve the problem, so test demand.
Is it legal to look at competitors' pricing and reviews?
Reading public pages and reviews is normal research. Do not copy their text, images or designs, and do not misrepresent who you are. Rules on competitive conduct differ by country, so ask a local advisor if you are unsure.
Do I need paid tools to do a competitor analysis?
No. A spreadsheet, a search engine and the public pages and reviews of each competitor are enough to start. Paid tools can add traffic estimates later, but treat those numbers as rough.
How often should I update my competitor analysis?
Do a short check monthly and a full redo every six months or when a major competitor changes its price or promise.
Keep reading
- What is competitive analysis?
- What is a value proposition?
- What is a SWOT analysis?
- Free SWOT analysis tool
- How to do customer interviews
- How to find your target market
- Best ChatGPT Alternatives for Startup Founders in 2026
- Fonda vs IdeaProof (2026): Which AI Idea Validator Can You Actually Trust?
- How to Find a Business Idea That Fits You
- How to Test a Business Idea Without Building It