Free calculator · No signup

Business Idea Validation Scorecard (Free)

Answer 10 questions about your problem, your evidence and your first customers. Get a score out of 100, a Go, Refine or Pivot result and the one test to run next.

Your answers

Pick the answer closest to what has already happened, not what you expect to happen. 1 is weakest, 5 is strongest. The line under each row shows what your answer means.

1. Problem urgency

How often does the problem come up, and what does it cost the people who have it?
Have people raised this problem without you bringing it up?

2. Evidence from real people

How many people in your target group have you talked to about the problem? Do not count friends or family.
What have people done beyond saying it sounds like a good idea?

3. Willingness to pay

Has anyone paid or committed money?
Do you know who would pay, and what they spend on the problem today?

4. Reaching your first 10 customers

Could you name your first 10 customers?
How would you reach them?

5. Founder fit

How well do you know this customer's world?
Could you build and sell the first version with the skills and time you have?

Your result

Result: Refine

60 / 100

Refine: some parts are promising and some are still guesses. Run the next test below before you build anything, then score the idea again.

Band
Refine
Weakest factor
Willingness to pay (37.5)

Score by factor

  • Problem urgency62.5
  • Evidence from real people50
  • Willingness to payWeakest37.5
  • Reaching your first 10 customers62.5
  • Founder fit87.5

Your next test

Ask for a pre-order

For your weakest factor: willingness to pay

Offer a small first batch or a paid pilot, at a real price, to the people who showed the most interest. A refundable deposit counts. Money changing hands, even a small amount, tells you more than any number of people saying they would buy.

Read: How to get pre-orders

This is a quick self-check of your own answers, so it is only as accurate as they are. The bands are a rule of thumb for this scorecard, not a research standard. Fonda's Verdict (go, refine or pivot, with reasons and a next step) comes after you research the market and talk to real customers.

Short answer

An idea validation scorecard rates a business idea on the evidence you already have: how urgent the problem is, what real people have done, whether anyone will pay, whether you can reach your first 10 customers and how well the idea fits you. This one turns 10 answers into a score out of 100. As a rule of thumb, 70 or more means Go, 45 to 69 means Refine and under 45 means Pivot.

Updated · Fonda editorial team ·How we write these pages

How to use the scorecard

  1. 1

    Answer from what has happened.

    Pick the answer that matches what people have already said and done, not what you hope they will do. A friend saying they would buy it is not evidence.

  2. 2

    Score one idea at a time.

    If you have several ideas, score each one separately, then compare the totals and the weakest factors.

  3. 3

    Read your weakest factor first.

    The total tells you where the idea stands. The weakest factor tells you what to test next, and the scorecard gives you one test for it.

  4. 4

    Score it again after each test.

    Your answers should change once you have new evidence. If none of them move, the test did not teach you much.

Each question uses a 1 to 5 scale with a plain description for every step, so a 3 means the same thing to everyone. The result updates as you answer. This is a quick self-check: it takes a few minutes and only reflects what you tell it.

The five factors and the test for each

Scroll sideways to see the whole table.

FactorWhat the two questions askNext test if it is your weakest
Problem urgencyHow often the problem comes up and what it costs, and whether people raise it without being askedFive problem interviews
Evidence from real peopleHow many people outside friends and family you have talked to, and what they did beyond giving complimentsA one-page offer
Willingness to payWhether anyone has paid or committed money, and whether you know who pays and what they spend nowA pre-order or paid pilot
Reaching your first 10 customersWhether you can name them, and whether you can reach them without paid adsA list of 50 people to contact
Founder fitHow well you know the customer's world, and whether you can build and sell the first version yourselfComparing it with ideas that fit you

The first three factors follow customer discovery, the method Steve Blank teaches: treat your plan as a set of untested guesses and check them with potential customers. In his words, there are no facts inside the building. The last two ask whether you can act on what you learn.

The scoring formula

Formula

Score = (sum of your 10 answers - 10) / 40 x 100. Factor score = (answer 1 + answer 2 - 2) / 8 x 100.

Each answer runs from 1 to 5, so each question adds 0 to 4 points and the 10 questions add up to 40 points at most. All 1s gives 0 and all 5s gives 100. Every question carries the same weight, so the total is also the average of the five factor scores. The weakest factor is the one with the lowest factor score. If two tie, the scorecard picks the one higher up the list, because a weak problem makes the later factors matter less.

A worked example

Say you managed a hair salon for years and want to run a booking and reminder service for independent salons, done by hand at first. Missed appointments cost owners money every week, and a few owners brought it up without your asking. You have talked to seven owners you did not know before, and several joined a waitlist. Some said they would pay, but no one has committed, and you have not talked about money yet. You could name ten salons nearby without contacting them yet, and you know the local groups where owners post.

Scroll sideways to see the whole table.

FactorYour answersFactor score
Problem urgency4 and 3(4 + 3 - 2) / 8 x 100 = 62.5
Evidence from real people3 and 3(3 + 3 - 2) / 8 x 100 = 50
Willingness to pay2 and 3(2 + 3 - 2) / 8 x 100 = 37.5
Reaching your first 10 customers4 and 3(4 + 3 - 2) / 8 x 100 = 62.5
Founder fit4 and 5(4 + 5 - 2) / 8 x 100 = 87.5
Total34(34 - 10) / 40 x 100 = 60

An example to show the maths, not data. These are the answers the scorecard starts with.

A score of 60 lands in Refine. The weakest factor is willingness to pay, so the next test is a pre-order: offer the first month of the service at a real price to the owners on the waitlist. If three of them pay, your first pay answer moves from 2 to 5 and the total rises to 67.5, just short of Go. Evidence from real people, at 50, then becomes the weakest factor and the next thing to test.

What Go, Refine and Pivot mean here

  • Go (70 to 100): the problem looks urgent, people have acted and some will pay. Move to a bigger test, such as a paid pilot or a small first batch. It does not mean quit your job or spend your savings.
  • Refine (45 to 69): parts of the idea hold up and parts are still guesses. Run the next test for your weakest factor before you build anything.
  • Pivot (0 to 44): most answers are guesses or point to a problem people are happy to live with. A pivot means changing the customer, the problem or the offer, not giving up.

A rule of thumb, not a standard

The 70 and 45 cut-offs are a rule of thumb for this self-check, not figures from a study. A score is only as honest as your answers. A high total can also hide one factor that is still a guess, so the scorecard warns you when you reach Go with a factor below 50.

Fonda's own Verdict works differently. In Fonda's Validate phase you research the market, list the key risks and talk to real customers, and only then get a Verdict of go, refine or pivot, with reasons and a next step. The method is based on peer-reviewed entrepreneurship research, described on the research behind Fonda.

How to answer honestly

  • Count actions, not compliments. Rob Fitzpatrick's book The Mom Test is about avoiding biased feedback and finding out whether someone is really going to buy. An email address, a booked call or a deposit counts. Praise does not.
  • Score the past, not the future. Y Combinator's Eric Migicovsky advises asking people about the last time they had the problem and what they have tried, instead of asking whether they would use a product. Apply the same rule to your own answers.
  • Leave out friends and family. They want to support you, so their answers lift your score without telling you much.
  • Score one narrow group. Paul Graham argues it is better to build something a small number of people want a lot than something many people want a little. If your answers are weak for a broad market, score the idea again for the group that needs it most.

What the scorecard leaves out

It does not measure market size, competition, costs or margins, and it cannot check whether your answers are true. Every question carries the same weight, although for some ideas one factor matters more than the rest. Size the market with the TAM SAM SOM calculator and work out whether each customer makes you money before you spend much. The scorecard runs in your browser and does not store your answers, so write your score down if you want to compare it after your next test.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good idea validation score?

On this scorecard, 70 or more is a Go, which means it is worth running a bigger test. That cut-off is a rule of thumb. A 75 built on friends' opinions is weaker than a 55 built on pre-orders, so look at what sits behind the number.

How many people should I talk to before I trust my score?

There is no fixed number. The evidence question gives its top answer at 20 or more conversations, which is a rule of thumb for this tool. What matters more is that the people are in your target group, are not friends or family, and told you about things that already happened.

Does a Pivot result mean my idea is bad?

No. It means your current evidence is thin or points to a problem people tolerate. Many ideas improve when you change one thing, such as the customer you serve or the problem you lead with. Change one thing, then score it again.

Can I use the scorecard to compare several ideas?

Yes. Score each idea on its own and compare both the totals and the weakest factors. An idea with a lower total but an easy next test can be a better place to start than one whose weakest factor is hard to fix.

Is this the same as Fonda's Verdict?

No. This is a quick self-check of your own answers. Fonda's Verdict comes after you research the market and interview real customers in the Validate phase, and it gives go, refine or pivot with reasons and a next step.

Is the scorecard free?

Yes. It runs in your browser, needs no signup and does not store your answers.

Sources

  1. Steve Blank: Customer discovery in the time of the Covid-19 virus
  2. Rob Fitzpatrick: The Mom Test
  3. Y Combinator: Startup School week 1 recap (Eric Migicovsky on talking to users)
  4. Paul Graham: How to Get Startup Ideas

Related tools and guides

Add this calculator to your website

Free to use on any site. Paste this code where you want the calculator to appear, and keep the credit link.

<iframe src="https://fonda.co/embed/idea-validation-scorecard" title="Business Idea Validation Scorecard (Free)" width="100%" height="720" style="border:0;max-width:960px" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<p style="font-size:13px"><a href="https://fonda.co/tools/idea-validation-scorecard">Business Idea Validation Scorecard (Free)</a> by Fonda</p>