Guide

How to Start a Recruiting Agency

Updated · Team Fonda

How to Start a Recruiting Agency

Short answer

To start a recruiting agency, pick a niche where you already know the roles and the people (say, nurses in one region or backend engineers for startups), sign a written fee agreement with two or three hiring companies before you build anything, and fill one role end to end. Check whether your city, state or country requires an employment agency license, decide between contingency and retained fees, and plan for cash flow, because you are often paid only after a candidate starts.

At a glance

Best for
People who know an industry's jobs and enjoy selling to both companies and candidates
Where you work
From home or a small office, mostly by phone, video and LinkedIn
Skills you need
Sourcing, screening, sales, negotiation, and keeping many conversations moving
Licenses to check
Employment agency license in some cities and states, plus local registration
First customers
Hiring managers you already know, founders, and firms with hard-to-fill roles
Fonda can help with
Testing your niche, customer interviews, a go or pivot Verdict, a business plan

Your roadmap

  1. 1Choose a niche you know
  2. 2Interview hiring managers first
  3. 3Pick a model
  4. 4Check licensing and registration
  5. 5Write your terms of business
  6. 6Sign two or three clients before sourcing
  7. 7Fill one role end to end
  8. 8Set up the business
  9. 9Build a candidate bench
  10. 10Hire only when roles pile up

Key takeaways

  • Your clients are the companies that pay you. Win a signed fee agreement before you spend weeks sourcing candidates.
  • A niche you know beats a general agency: you speak the language, you know where candidates are and you get referrals.
  • Some places license employment agencies. New York City and New York State are two examples, so check your own location.
  • Contingency fees arrive after a hire starts, and replacement clauses can claw them back, so plan cash for several lean months.

Is a recruiting agency right for you?

Recruiting is a sales job on two sides. You sell your service to hiring managers, then you sell a role to people who are often not looking. The days are full of calls: role intake meetings, sourcing, screening, interview scheduling, chasing feedback, handling counteroffers and negotiating salaries. Deals fall apart late for reasons you do not control, like a budget freeze or a rival offer.

It suits people who have worked in an industry or in in-house recruiting and already know who hires and who gets hired. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics Occupational Outlook Handbook page for human resources specialists, the group that includes recruitment specialists, says they find, screen and interview applicants for job openings. It puts the median annual wage at $75,940 in May 2025 and says 13 percent work in employment services. If you are leaving an in-house role, that is a reference point for what your time was worth.

What works in your favour

  • Low startup cost: a laptop, a phone, a sourcing tool and a contract template
  • One placement fee can be a large payment relative to your costs
  • Relationships compound: placed candidates become hiring managers who call you later
  • You can start alone and from home in many places, subject to local rules

What to be ready for

  • Income is lumpy and depends on hiring cycles you cannot control
  • Contingency work means you can do weeks of sourcing and earn nothing
  • Replacement clauses can force a free re-search if a hire leaves early
  • Anti-discrimination and data privacy rules apply to how you advertise and screen

How to start a recruiting agency, step by step

  1. 1

    Choose a niche you know.

    Pick an industry, a role family and a region, such as warehouse supervisors in the Midwest or product designers for fintech. You should be able to name 50 people who hold the role today.

  2. 2

    Interview hiring managers first.

    Ask 10 to 15 of them which roles they struggled to fill last year, how long it took, who they used, what they paid and what annoyed them about agencies. Do not offer to work a role on these calls. The aim is to learn, and how to validate a startup idea explains how to keep it that way.

  3. 3

    Pick a model.

    Decide between permanent placement (the client employs the hire directly) and contract staffing (you employ the worker and bill the client). Staffing needs payroll and far more cash.

  4. 4

    Check licensing and registration.

    Find out whether your city, state or country licenses employment agencies before you take a fee. See the section below.

  5. 5

    Write your terms of business.

    Fee basis, payment terms, what counts as an introduction, how long a candidate introduction stays valid, and the replacement or refund policy. Have an employment lawyer review it.

  6. 6

    Sign two or three clients before sourcing.

    Get a signed agreement and a detailed job intake for each role. Work on roles where the hiring manager will talk to you weekly.

  7. 7

    Fill one role end to end.

    Source, screen, present a short list, manage the offer and stay close until the start date. Track your hours to learn your real cost per placement.

  8. 8

    Set up the business.

    Register, open a separate bank account, choose an applicant tracking system and get professional liability cover from a broker.

  9. 9

    Build a candidate bench.

    Keep in touch with strong people you did not place. They are your fastest shortlist for the next role in the niche.

  10. 10

    Hire only when roles pile up.

    Add a sourcer when you have more signed roles than you can work properly.

What it costs to start a recruiting agency

A permanent placement agency is cheap to open and expensive to run without placements, because your main cost is months of your own time before the first fee lands. List each line and get quotes, then add them up in the startup cost calculator.

Scroll sideways to see the whole table.

Cost itemWhat it coversNotes
Sourcing toolsLinkedIn recruiter seat, job board postings, contact data toolsThe biggest monthly cost for most solo recruiters. Start with one tool.
Applicant tracking systemCandidate database, pipelines, email templates, notesChoose one that helps with data privacy requests and deletion
Licensing and registrationBusiness registration, any employment agency license, bondsSome jurisdictions require a surety bond and an inspection
LegalTerms of business, candidate privacy notice, lawyer reviewA one-time cost that protects every fee you earn
InsuranceProfessional liability, general liabilitySome clients ask for proof before they sign
Living costs runwayYour income while early fees are pendingThe cost founders most often forget
Payroll and workers' compensationOnly if you place contractors on your own payrollStaffing needs a lot more working capital than placement

Sourcing tool seats and license fees depend on your country, state and plan, so this table lists categories only. Check the current price of each line before you commit.

Licenses, registration and compliance for recruiters

Recruiting is regulated differently from place to place. In some cities and states you need an employment agency license before you charge a fee. In others you only register the business. Check your own city, state and country. These examples show what the rules can look like.

  • New York City. The NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection says you must have an Employment Agency license to provide job assistance for a fee. A staffing agency that is the employer, with all its workers receiving a W-2 from it, does not need this license.
  • New York State. The New York State Department of Labor's information for new applicants quotes state law that no one may operate an employment agency without first getting a license. It lists fingerprints for each principal, a surety bond of $5,000, statements of character and a site inspection before a license is issued.
  • England, Scotland and Wales. The UK government's overview of the Conduct Regulations 2003 says agencies are prohibited from charging work-seekers fees for finding them jobs, with exceptions such as some entertainment work and modeling, and that terms must be agreed with work-seekers before services begin. It names the Fair Work Agency as the regulator. The same page says agencies supplying workers to agriculture, horticulture, shellfish gathering and related food processing need a gangmaster license from that agency.
  • Anti-discrimination. In the US, the EEOC says it is illegal for an employer, employment agency or union to take protected characteristics into account when making job referrals, and illegal for an employer to publish a job ad that shows a preference based on them. Since you often write ads on a client's behalf, write neutral job ads and screen on job requirements only.
  • Candidate data. You hold resumes, salaries and contact details. Ask a lawyer which data protection rules apply where you and your candidates are.

Watch out

In many places, charging candidates a fee to find them a job is restricted or banned. Build your agency so that the hiring company pays.

How to price recruiting services

Recruiting fees are usually a percentage of the hire's first-year base salary. On contingency, you are paid only if your candidate is hired. On a retained search, the client pays part of the fee up front and the rest at milestones, in return for your exclusive effort. Some recruiters also offer a flat fee per hire or an hourly rate for sourcing only. Whatever you choose, state the fee, payment terms and replacement period in the agreement.

Here is an example with made-up numbers. Say you agree a 20 percent contingency fee and place an engineer at a $120,000 base salary. The fee is $24,000, invoiced on the start date with 30-day payment terms. If the role took 60 hours of your time, that is $400 an hour. But if you worked three other roles that month for 60 hours each and filled none, your real rate is $100 an hour. Your fill rate matters as much as your fee percentage.

Because fees land weeks after a hire is agreed, map expected start dates and payment terms in the cash flow forecast calculator, then use the break-even calculator to see how many placements a year cover your tools, insurance and income.

How to get your first recruiting clients

  • Former colleagues who now hire. Managers who know your judgment are your strongest early leads.
  • Companies with stale job ads. A role advertised for weeks is a sign of pain. Contact the hiring manager with two or three anonymized candidate profiles.
  • Funded startups in your niche. Teams that just raised money often need to hire several people quickly and have no in-house recruiter.
  • Industry events and associations. Show up where your candidates and clients meet.
  • Placed candidates. Stay in touch after the start date. Today's hire is often tomorrow's hiring manager.

If you come from HR, the business ideas for HR professionals list covers related services, such as HR consulting, that can sit alongside recruiting.

Common mistakes new recruiting agencies make

  • Sending resumes without a signed agreement. A client can hire your candidate and dispute the fee. Get terms signed first.
  • Taking every role. Roles outside your niche mean slower shortlists.
  • Too many contingency searches at once. Ten roles shared with three other agencies each usually produce fewer placements than three roles where the client works closely with you.
  • Ignoring the replacement clause. A long free-replacement period can wipe out a quarter's income if two hires leave early.
  • Biased job ads and screening. Words that signal age, gender or background preferences create legal risk for you and your client.

What to do this week

  • Write down your niche: industry, role family and region.
  • List 20 hiring managers in that niche and book calls with five of them.
  • Check your city, state or country for an employment agency license and note what it asks for.
  • Draft terms of business with fee, payment terms and replacement period, and book a lawyer review.
  • Pick one sourcing tool and one tracking system to start with.
  • Work out how many months of living costs you can cover before the first fee is paid.

If you want help testing your niche before you leave a salaried job, Fonda takes you through market research, interviews with real hiring managers and a go, refine or pivot Verdict, and it is free to start. For the plan itself, the consulting business plan template fits a fee-based professional service like recruiting.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a license to start a recruiting agency?

It depends on where you operate. New York City requires an Employment Agency license to provide job assistance for a fee, and New York State law says no one may operate an employment agency without first getting a license. In England, Scotland and Wales, the government's Conduct Regulations overview sets conduct rules for agencies and mentions a license only for gangmasters. Check your own city, state and country before charging a fee.

What is the difference between a recruiting agency and a staffing agency?

A recruiting agency finds candidates whom the client then employs directly, and earns a placement fee. A staffing agency employs the workers itself, pays their wages and bills the client by the hour. Staffing needs payroll, insurance and much more cash.

Can I start a recruiting agency with no recruiting experience?

You can if you know an industry well, because knowing the roles and the people is half the job. Expect to learn sourcing and offer negotiation on the way. Working a few roles with an experienced recruiter as a partner shortens that learning.

Should I work on contingency or retained search?

Many new agencies start on contingency because clients see no risk. As you build a record, ask for retained or partly retained terms on senior or hard roles. Retained work gives you committed clients and cash earlier.

Can I charge candidates for finding them a job?

Often not. In England, Scotland and Wales, the government says agencies are prohibited from charging work-seekers fees for finding them jobs, with exceptions such as performers and photographic and fashion models. Rules elsewhere differ, so check locally and build your model so employers pay.

Sources

  1. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook: Human resources specialists
  2. NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection: Employment Agency license checklist
  3. New York State Department of Labor: Employment agency information for new applicants (LS 355.3)
  4. GOV.UK: Overview of the Conduct Regulations 2003
  5. U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission: Prohibited employment policies and practices

Keep reading